Admiral Muhammad Ali, during a press conference on February 6, highlighted the potential need for an aircraft carrier to bolster Indonesia's non-war military operations. Speaking to reporters from Antara, the national news agency, he emphasized the vessel's utility in humanitarian assistance, disaster relief, and maritime security. However, not all experts are convinced that this is the right strategic move for the Indonesian navy.
"It seems that we need an aircraft carrier for non-war military operations." – Admiral Muhammad Ali
Despite the allure of an aircraft carrier as a symbol of naval prowess, some observers question its practicality for Indonesia's specific needs. Abdul Rahman Yaacob, a research fellow at the Lowy Institute, expressed skepticism about the strategic and operational logic behind acquiring an aircraft carrier solely for non-combat roles. His concerns are shared by others who believe that Indonesia's resources might be better allocated elsewhere.
Indonesia, with its sprawling archipelago of over 17,000 islands and location along one of the world's most contested waterways, faces unique maritime challenges. Its navy bears the daunting task of safeguarding these waters, a mission that has recently seen the acquisition of two Italian frigates and plans for further upgrades. As part of a broader modernization effort, the Indonesian navy is seeking to enhance its capabilities to effectively protect its vast maritime territory.
The debate over whether an aircraft carrier should be part of these upgrades remains contentious. While such a vessel is often regarded as the crown jewel of naval power, many argue that its role should be carefully considered in relation to Indonesia's specific security needs. The focus on non-combat operations raises questions about whether an aircraft carrier would be the most efficient and effective tool for achieving these objectives.
Leave a Reply