An incident involving the display of China's flags during a cultural event in Muar, Johor, has sparked widespread debate. The event, organized by the Muar Tiong Hua Association to celebrate its 20th anniversary, featured a dragon puppet adorned with the Jalur Gemilang, Malaysia's national flag, on its right flank and flags of China on its left. This display was part of a cultural procession meant to symbolize friendship and international camaraderie. However, it has drawn significant attention and outrage from netizens, prompting a police investigation.
The organizer of the event, Dr. Lim Teck Guan, addressed the controversy by stating that there was "no intention to fuel racial hate" or promote "pro-China sentiments." The incident was labeled a "misunderstanding," with Dr. Lim clarifying that the Chinese flags were displayed by foreign delegates attending the event. The Guan Gong Cultural Association also issued an apology, emphasizing that it was a gesture of friendship and cultural exchange.
“No intention to fuel racial hate” – Dr Lim Teck Guan
Despite the outrage on social media, the police investigation concluded without any charges being filed. Dr. Lim confirmed that the probe had been "settled," aligning with the sentiment that the incident was a misunderstanding rather than a deliberate provocation.
“We want to be part of the international community and thus, the display of foreign flags and emblems do not carry the same negative connotation as before and, instead, shows friendship and togetherness.” – Syahredzan
Tourism, Arts and Culture Minister Tiong King Sing expressed concerns that the "overreaction" to the waving of Chinese flags could have adverse effects on tourism. He highlighted that fostering international relations through cultural events is crucial for Malaysia's image as a welcoming destination.
The incident raises questions about the National Emblems (Control of Display) Act 1949, which regulates the display of foreign flags in Malaysia. Under this act, displaying a foreign flag is punishable by up to six months' imprisonment, a fine not exceeding RM1,000, or both. Despite this legislation, similar incidents involving China's flags have occurred at cultural events in Tangkak and Perak. These events were also viewed as celebrations of cultural exchange rather than political statements.
“There have not been prosecutions, which would have sent ‘the wrong message’, especially if the waving of flags was borne of friendship or solidarity.” – Syahredzan
PAS deputy president Ibrahim Man described such displays as a "celebration of cultural exchange," encouraging Malaysians to embrace diversity and international friendships. This perspective aligns with views from experts who see these gestures as symbols of friendship and solidarity rather than political alignment.
“symbol of friendship and solidarity” – Expert (no name mentioned)
Syahredzan added that there is no double standard in how authorities handle such matters. He noted that the only reason police do not investigate other foreign flags, like those of Palestine, is simply because no complaints have been filed. He also pointed out how certain groups might exploit these incidents for their own agendas, including political parties.
“Unfortunately, certain quarters have decided to do so for their own agendas, including political parties.” – Syahredzan
Leave a Reply