The U.S. Preventative Services Task Force has issued a new draft recommendation stating that vitamin D supplements do not prevent falls or fractures in older adults. This update revises the previous belief that vitamin D supplementation could serve as a protective measure for bone health among the elderly. The task force's conclusions are based on an analysis of 20 unique randomized, controlled studies published across 54 different research papers. These studies collectively found that additional vitamin D supplementation for postmenopausal women and older men with normal vitamin D levels, no previous fractures, and no bone density issues was unnecessary.
In 2018, the task force recommended that postmenopausal women refrain from supplementing with 400 units or less of vitamin D and 1,000 milligrams or less of calcium for the primary prevention of fractures. Notably, this recommendation did not include men. Recent research has provided further support for this position, showing no benefits of vitamin D supplementation in reducing fracture risk, cardiovascular disease, cancer prevention, or mortality.
“Vitamin D was once considered a panacea for a variety of ailments but now is considered by some to be unimportant. Many recent, large, well-conducted studies have shown no benefits in reducing fracture risk, cardiovascular disease, cancer prevention, or death from vitamin D supplementation,” Cutler said.
The new findings suggest that many individuals may not need extra vitamin D supplements. While vitamin D was once hailed as a universal remedy for various health issues, its perceived importance has diminished. According to the updated recommendation, neither vitamin D supplements alone nor combined with calcium have a significant effect on preventing falls or fractures in older adults.
“The appropriate conclusion is not that patients do not need any vitamin D but more correctly that patients with adequate amounts of vitamin D will not reduce their fracture risk by additional supplementation.”— David Cutler, MD
The task force's recommendation highlights the need to consider individual health circumstances when addressing vitamin D supplementation. The research analyzed by the task force found that the severity of injuries from falls was not affected by vitamin D intake. However, researchers believe there may be a link between long-term vitamin D deficiency and autoimmune conditions like type 1 diabetes and rheumatoid arthritis. Further research is needed to confirm this connection.
“Addressing the issue of vitamin D supplementation with your physician requires looking at all the potential benefits and risks in the context of your personal health situation. This includes addressing diet for adequate calcium intake, exercise for fall prevention, and genetic factors that may affect the risk of kidney stones. So, it is only by comprehensively evaluating your entire health status that an appropriate recommendation for vitamin D supplementation can be made,” Cutler said.
Some experts have suggested alternative ways to obtain vitamin D safely, such as sun exposure. This recommendation remains controversial due to concerns about increased skin cancer risk from sunlight. Others propose that simply being outdoors and engaging in physical activities might improve health outcomes independently of increased vitamin D levels.
“Some experts suggested that vitamin D could be obtained safely from sun exposure, a recommendation that was considered controversial because of a potentially increased risk of skin cancer. Other experts suggested that perhaps being outdoors with sun exposure caused improved health outcomes independent of increased vitamin D. Needless to say, this nuanced balancing of benefits and risks is difficult for experts, let alone the average person, to reconcile,” Cutler explained.
Leave a Reply